Why Western Digital is not Answering on Failed SSD Drives

Western Digital is not answering questions about their failed SSD drives because they don’t know exactly where the problem lies. The three main components for any SSD drive will be the PCB board, the on-board chipset that controls the flow of information between the host PC and the memory and of course, the NAND memory itself. If we break this down a bit more, we might find out what the reason is.

Background (PCB, USB Controller, NAND Memory)

The PCB board

Printed Circuit Boards, or PCBs, play a vital role in modern electronics. They are like the backbone of electronic devices, providing a platform for components to be connected, organized, and powered. Let’s break down their value, design process, testing, and impact on soldered components.

Value of PCBs:
A PCB serves as a foundation for electronic components to work together. It’s like a puzzle board with electrical pathways etched onto it, allowing components like resistors, capacitors, microchips, and more to communicate and function properly. Without PCBs, it would be incredibly difficult and messy to manually connect all these components together.

Designing PCBs:
The process of designing a PCB involves several steps:

Schematic Design:
Engineers create a schematic diagram, which is like a blueprint showing how components are connected. This helps plan the layout of the PCB.

PCB Layout:
Using specialized software, the engineer arranges components on the PCB, considering factors like size, heat dissipation, and signal integrity. This layout involves placing components and drawing the electrical pathways (traces) that connect them.

This step involves deciding the exact paths for the traces to minimize interference and ensure efficient operation. High-speed components may require careful consideration to maintain signal quality.

PCBs often have multiple layers, allowing for more complex designs. Each layer can carry different traces, making the most of the available space.

Once the layout is finalized, components are attached to the PCB using soldering techniques. Surface Mount Technology (SMT) and Through-Hole Technology (THT) are commonly used methods.

Testing PCBs:
Testing ensures that the PCB functions as intended and helps catch any errors before mass production. There are a few ways to test PCBs:

Visual Inspection:
Engineers visually check for any obvious issues such as soldering defects or incorrect component placement.

Continuity Testing:
This involves checking if the expected electrical connections exist between components and traces. Multimeters can help with this.

Functional Testing:
PCBs are powered up, and their performance is checked to ensure that all components are working as expected. This can involve running specific test programs or performing specific tasks to evaluate functionality.

Impact on Soldered Components:
Components soldered to a PCB are connected to it through solder joints. These joints are vital for the proper functioning of the device. The quality of soldering affects the overall reliability and performance of the PCB. Poor soldering can lead to bad connections, signal interruptions, and even complete device failure.

PCBs are crucial for modern electronics as they provide a structured platform for components to work together. Their design involves careful planning, layout, and routing of components and traces. Testing ensures proper functionality, and the quality of soldered components directly impacts the overall reliability and performance of the PCB and the device it’s a part of.

USB Controller

Let’s dive into USB controllers and their role in solid-state hard drives (SSDs) and flash drives.

USB Controller:
A USB controller, also known as a USB interface controller, is a microchip that manages the communication between a USB device (like an SSD or flash drive) and a host computer. It’s responsible for controlling the data transfer, handling power management, and interpreting the USB protocol.

Usage with SSDs and Flash Drives:
In the context of solid-state hard drives (SSDs) and flash drives, the USB controller is a critical component. It handles the interaction between the device and the computer, making it possible to read and write data to and from the storage memory chips inside the SSD or flash drive.

Type of Information Controlled:
The USB controller manages various aspects of data transfer and device functionality, including:

Data Transfer:
It controls the transfer of data between the host computer and the storage chips in the device. This involves managing the flow of data, error correction, and ensuring efficient utilization of the USB bandwidth.

Error Correction:
The controller employs error correction techniques to ensure data integrity during transmission and storage. This is crucial to prevent data corruption.

Wear Leveling (for SSDs):
In SSDs, the controller handles wear leveling, which ensures even distribution of write and erase cycles across the memory cells. This prolongs the lifespan of the SSD.

Bad Block Management:
The controller identifies and manages bad blocks or sectors on the storage chips, preventing them from being used and preserving data reliability.

Power Management:
It regulates power consumption, allowing the device to enter low-power states when not in use.

Interactions with Host Computers and Peripherals:
USB controllers interact with various types of host computers and peripherals, as USB is a widely used standard. They can connect to desktop computers, laptops, tablets, smartphones, and many other devices. Additionally, USB controllers can interact with various peripherals like printers, cameras, keyboards, mice, and of course, USB storage devices like SSDs and flash drives.

USB Protocol Used:
USB controllers use the Universal Serial Bus (USB) protocol for communication. The USB protocol defines how data is transferred, how devices are recognized and configured, and how power is managed. There are different generations of the USB protocol, such as USB 2.0, USB 3.0 (also known as USB 3.1 Gen 1), USB 3.1 (also known as USB 3.1 Gen 2), and USB 3.2, each offering different data transfer rates and capabilities.

USB controllers play a crucial role in managing the communication and data transfer between USB storage devices like SSDs and flash drives and host computers or other peripherals. They ensure efficient data transfer, error correction, wear leveling (for SSDs), and power management. USB controllers use the USB protocol to establish connections and manage data exchange between devices.

NAND Memory

NAND Memory:
NAND memory is a type of non-volatile storage technology used in various electronic devices, including SSDs, USB flash drives, smartphones, and memory cards. It’s called “NAND” because it’s based on the NAND logic gate, a fundamental building block in digital circuits.

NAND memory works by arranging memory cells in a grid-like structure, where data is stored as charges in the cells’ floating gate transistors. Unlike volatile memory (like RAM), NAND memory retains data even when power is removed. However, it requires specialized control circuits to manage data storage and retrieval.

Connection to PCB and USB Controllers:
In devices like SSDs and USB flash drives, NAND memory chips are connected to the Printed Circuit Board (PCB) along with a USB controller. The USB controller manages the communication between the NAND memory and the USB interface, enabling data transfer between the storage medium and the host device.

The connection between NAND memory and the USB controller involves high-speed data buses that transfer data back and forth. The USB controller is responsible for managing these data buses, ensuring proper error correction, wear leveling, bad block management, and other critical functions.

Manufacturers of NAND Memory:
Several major companies manufacture NAND memory chips, including:

A prominent player in the semiconductor industry, Samsung produces a wide range of NAND flash memory chips for various applications.

SK Hynix:
Another leading memory manufacturer, SK Hynix produces NAND memory for SSDs, mobile devices, and other electronics.

Micron is known for its NAND flash memory solutions used in various consumer and enterprise applications.

Western Digital (WD):
WD produces NAND memory through its subsidiary, SanDisk, offering flash storage solutions for various devices.

Toshiba Memory (now Kioxia):
Toshiba was a significant player in NAND memory production before its memory division became Kioxia Corporation.

Selling NAND Memory:
NAND memory is sold to other companies that incorporate it into their products. These companies include device manufacturers like SSD producers, USB flash drive makers, smartphone manufacturers, and more. NAND memory chips are sold in various capacities (measured in gigabytes or terabytes) to suit the needs of different applications.

Customers typically purchase NAND memory chips in bulk, and these chips are then soldered onto the PCBs of devices during the manufacturing process. The integration of NAND memory into various products allows for the creation of storage solutions with different capacities and performance characteristics.

NAND memory is a type of non-volatile storage technology used in various electronic devices. It’s connected to PCBs alongside USB controllers to enable data transfer and management. Major manufacturers like Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron, and others produce NAND memory chips that are sold in bulk to device manufacturers who integrate them into their products.

Considering the above the highest probability is the USB controller having issues with their firmware and how that firmware interacts with the NAND memory. Western Digital is not open about the brand of USB controller they use, so hard to say. We do know that since Western Digital and SanDisk to not make the USB controller it means they rely on a 3rd party vendor to solve their problem. Until this problem is resolved, we won’t know for sure why the Western Digital. Would you want to risk your data by storing it on a Western Digital hard drive after reading this article?

Tags: , ,

Mark McCrosky

Kicking around in technology since 2002. I like to write about technology products and ideas, but at the consumer level understanding. Some tech, but not too techie. Posting on Quora.com as well.

Copyright ©

Copyright © 2011-2019 by
USB Powered Gadgets and more…
All rights reserved.

SD Card Duplicator Equipment

GetFlashMemory.info has reviewed SD Card Duplicators by Nexcopy.  Our results found the product to be reliable, fast and accurate.

They manufacture both PC connected and standalone systems to fit any type application

Custom Shape USB Media

Turn your product into a custom USB shape. Right down to the last detail. Click to see over 30 examples of custom shape USB drives.